Recruitment Careers: Corporate vs Independent

Rebecca Crowther • 7 October 2019

Whether you’re a seasoned recruiter or only just thinking about starting a recruitment career, it can be difficult to decide which agency you may want to work for. Especially when there are so many recruitment agencies to choose from.


The last report stated there were nearly 40,000 recruitment agencies registered in the UK.

We spoke to Claire Roberts, a Senior Recruitment Consultant who has worked for both a large corporate and more recently a smaller independent agency to give you an idea of what it’s like to work in both types of recruitment environments.

Can you give us a quick overview of your recruitment career so far?


I started my recruitment career 10 years ago when I moved to the Midlands from the Wirral. I didn’t set out to work in recruitment. I visited a well-known agency to register and get help with finding work. It was during a conversation with a member of their team that they asked if I would consider working in recruitment and the rest is history.


To begin with, I worked as a Recruitment Consultant covering permanent commercial roles. After 3 years, I started to climb the ladder, working up from Consultant to a Senior Branch Manager position over a number of years.


More recently, I went back to being a Recruitment Consultant as I missed the recruitment bit which you don’t do as much of when you reach a management level.


What made you change to an independent recruitment agency after 10 years in a corporate environment?


After 10 years at a corporate agency, I decided I needed a new challenge and a role closer to home as I was missing out on lots of time with my son due to the commute. I was then contacted by a local agency and after 2 interviews I was offered the role and decided to make the move. The structure and plans they had in place for when I joined sounded like a great opportunity.


Do you wish you’d moved sooner?


I am happy the way I have progressed in my career and wouldn’t change this. The experience I gained over the last 10 years has given me the right ingredients to be successful at an independent agency. I felt I could come in and hit the ground running from day one.


What are the best bits about working for an independent agency compared to a corporate?

  • Being given the autonomy to get on with your job and manage your own time and desk how you want rather than having to follow strict timetables
  • Being able to run a Hybrid desk
  • Relaxed yet professional environment
  • Being able to cover the whole of the UK rather than a small patch


Can you give an overview of the difference in the following areas between the two types of recruitment agencies?


TRAINING


The large corporate agency offered a 5-year training programme and you then also received training throughout the year. This was great for trainee consultants.


Having said that, the Independent agency provides a structured 12-week training academy programme for those new to recruitment. There is also both internal and external training for the team at all levels.


CULTURE


The corporate agency had a very formal dress code and strict rules on locations and specialisms you were allowed to recruit for.


The Independent agency has given me the freedom to recruit for any office role in any location meaning I have more scope to succeed. They are also less formal in dress code but maintain a professional image. It’s just an overall more relaxed and friendly culture.


WORKING STRUCTURE


The Corporate agency was very strict in the way you plan your day, such as outlining tasks you need to achieve on a daily basis. Tasks and targets have to be done by a certain time.


In comparison, although the Independent agency does set KPIs and daily tasks there is more flexibility in how you plan your day. In short, this means you can get on with your job and have more time to recruit which is what you’re there to do. Also, guidance and assistance are readily provided if you need it.


What advice would you give someone undecided on working for a corporate vs an independent?


Large corporate agencies have the ability to offer full training programmes but can be very strict on KPI’s and area’s you can work. Whereas, Independent agencies are more flexible and give you the opportunity to work on a wide range of roles across various locations. Furthermore, they also give you the support you need to achieve these results with training and the help of other consultants. I feel my knowledge has expanded more since joining the independent agency but the corporate gave me a good start. Also, the less formal environment of the independent agency is a real plus for me.


I think your choice of recruitment agency really depends on the environment you feel you’d fit best. I’d suggest (if possible), visiting both and gaining a feel for yourself before making a decision.


What Next?


ASC is an independently owned agency who are always looking for driven, ambitious and lively people to join our team. If this sounds like you, contact our Internal Recruiter, Marie who will be happy to have an informal chat with you.

Rebecca Crowther is a Marketing Executive for ASC Connections. Her love for writing started when she was young. In her current role, she loves creating content to support candidates on their career journey and help clients hire talented individuals.

SHARE BLOG

The Benefits of Temporary Staffing: How Flexible Hiring Can Help Your Business Grow

28 March 2025
Finding the right talent at the right time is a challenge for many businesses. Whether you’re managing seasonal peaks, covering staff absences or scaling operations, temporary staffing can be a game-changer. By leveraging flexible hiring solutions, businesses can remain agile, control costs and access skilled professionals without long-term commitments. In this article, we explore the key benefits of temporary staffing and how it can drive business growth. 1. Scalability and Flexibility Business demands fluctuate and workforce needs change accordingly. Temporary staffing allows you to scale up or down depending on workload and market conditions. Retailers benefit from temporary hires during busy seasons. Event companies can staff up for major conferences and exhibitions. Manufacturing firms can adjust workforce levels to meet production demands. By integrating temporary workers, businesses avoid the risk of overstaffing during slow periods and understaffing during peak times. 2. Reduced Hiring Risks and Costs Permanent hires come with significant financial commitments, from salaries to benefits and severance packages. Temporary staffing offers a cost-effective alternative. No long-term salary commitments Reduced expenses on benefits and training Minimised legal and compliance risks Recruitment agencies handle vetting, onboarding and payroll, allowing businesses to focus on core operations while ensuring they have access to qualified professionals. 3. Access to Specialised Skills Certain projects or short-term needs require niche expertise that may not exist in-house. Temporary staffing enables businesses to bring in specialists without the cost of a full-time hire. Engineering firms can contract design engineers for specific product development. Manufacturing companies can hire CNC machinists to manage increased production. Warehousing operations can bring in forklift operators and logistics coordinators to handle inventory surges. With an extensive pool of pre-screened professionals, recruitment agencies can match businesses with the right talent quickly and efficiently. 4. Faster Hiring Process Time-to-hire is a critical factor in maintaining business efficiency. Traditional hiring processes can take weeks, but recruitment agencies can provide qualified candidates within days. Pre-screened candidates are ready to start immediately. Agencies manage the recruitment process, saving businesses time. Temporary hires can be converted to permanent roles if they prove to be a great fit. This agility allows businesses to maintain momentum and productivity without prolonged gaps. Overall Temporary staffing is a powerful strategy that helps businesses stay competitive, responsive and cost-effective. Whether you need to fill short-term gaps, scale your workforce or access specialised skills, flexible hiring solutions provide a reliable answer. Looking for the right temporary staff for your business? Get in touch with us today and let our experts connect you with top talent, exactly when you need it!
A person is stacking wooden blocks with arrows on them on a table.

Top Hiring Trends in 2025 – What’s Changing in the Job Market?

28 February 2025
The job market is rapidly changing because of technological progress, evolving worker expectations and shifts in the economy. By 2025, it's crucial for both employers and job seekers to stay informed about hiring trends to remain competitive. Here are the major trends influencing recruitment in 2025: AI and Automation in Recruitment AI is revolutionising the hiring process. It automates CV screening, facilitates candidate chats and predicts the best job matches. Recruiters use AI tools to streamline hiring, speed up processes and ensure fairness. Companies investing in AI gain an advantage in attracting and hiring top talent. Skills Over Degrees Companies are changing how they hire. They aren't as focused on degrees anymore. Instead, they care more about the skills you have. Employers are looking for practical skills, certifications and real-world experience. They want to know what you can do, not just what you studied in university. People with the right skills are finding more job opportunities, even if they learned through online classes or training programs. It's crucial to show what you can do and the skills you've gained, no matter where or how you learned them. Hybrid and Remote Work Becoming the Norm The need for flexible work setups is rising. People often prefer hybrid work, splitting time between home and the office or working entirely from home. As a result, companies are developing policies to support employees working from various locations. Those businesses that provide these flexible options are more likely to draw in and keep talented professionals, especially in a competitive job market. Focus on Employee Well-being and Work-Life Balance Balancing work and personal life, along with focusing on mental health, is crucial for hiring. Companies invest in wellness programs, mental health support and flexible work hours to increase employee happiness. By creating a healthy and supportive workplace, businesses become more attractive to job seekers. Diversity, Equity and Inclusion (DEI) at the Forefront Employing individuals from diverse backgrounds is essential for companies. They strive to build workplaces where everyone feels included and valued. To accomplish this, businesses employ strategies like blind hiring, which hides names and backgrounds during the initial selection process. They also make sure their interview panels are made up of people from different backgrounds. Additionally, they actively seek out talented individuals who are underrepresented in their fields. Work environments that embrace diversity tend to generate innovative ideas and achieve better business outcomes. Rise of the Freelance Workforce The freelance economy is growing and more people are choosing freelance or project-based work instead of traditional full-time jobs. Companies are turning to online platforms to find skilled workers for short-term projects. By adopting this flexible hiring model, businesses can access a wider range of talented individuals. Generative AI and Upskilling in the Workplace With AI tools like ChatGPT changing industries, employees need to learn new technology skills. Companies are providing training programs to help workers get AI expertise, ensuring they remain competitive in the shifting job market. Being open to learning and adapting is essential for career success. Data-Driven Hiring Decisions Recruiters are enhancing their hiring strategies through data analysis. By forecasting trends, planning workforce requirements and monitoring employee performance, businesses can make more informed hiring decisions. Companies that prioritize data-driven hiring will attract better candidates and decrease employee turnover. Employer Branding Matters More Than Ever Candidates looking for jobs these days do a lot of research on companies before they apply. Companies that have a good reputation, share positive stories from their employees and have clear values tend to attract the best candidates. When a company communicates openly and supports its workers, it really stands out from the competition. Final Thoughts In 2025, the way companies hire is changing a lot, driven by technology, flexibility and inclusivity. Businesses that adopt AI, focus on hiring for skills and support work-life balance are likely to attract the best employees. Job seekers should align with these new expectations to remain competitive. Keeping informed and taking proactive steps are crucial for success in this evolving job landscape.
A group of people are sitting around a table with laptops.

Understanding Generational Differences in the Workplace

31 January 2025
In today’s workforce, multiple generations work side by side, each bringing unique perspectives, values and work styles. Understanding these generational differences is key to fostering a productive and harmonious work environment. The Generations at Work Baby Boomers (Born 1946-1964) Baby Boomers value loyalty, hard work and hierarchical structures. They tend to prefer face-to-face communication and have a strong work ethic, often associating job success with long hours and dedication. Generation X (Born 1965-1980) Often called the “middle child” of generations, Gen Xers are independent, resourceful and adaptable. They witnessed the rise of technology and value work-life balance. They prefer direct communication and are comfortable with both traditional and digital communication methods. Millennials (Born 1981-1996) Millennials prioritise collaboration, purpose-driven work and flexibility. They are tech-savvy and prefer open, transparent communication. They seek regular feedback and value career development opportunities, often looking for meaningful work over long-term job security. Generation Z (Born 1997-2012) The newest entrants into the workforce, Gen Zers are true digital natives. They value diversity, inclusion and innovation. They prefer instant communication methods, such as messaging apps and social media, and are drawn to organisations that align with their values and offer work-life integration. Bridging the Generational Gap To create an inclusive workplace that leverages the strengths of each generation, organisations can implement the following strategies: Encourage Open Communication : Foster a culture where employees feel comfortable sharing their perspectives. Utilising multiple communication channels (emails, meetings, messaging apps) ensures that all generations stay informed. Emphasize Mentorship and Reverse Mentorship : Pairing Baby Boomers or Gen X employees with Millennials or Gen Zers promotes knowledge exchange and strengthens intergenerational relationships. Promote Flexibility : Recognising different work styles and preferences—such as remote work options or flexible schedules—can increase job satisfaction and productivity. Leverage Strengths : Assign roles and responsibilities that align with generational strengths. For example, Gen Z’s digital fluency can drive technological innovation, while Baby Boomers’ experience can guide strategic decision-making. Invest in Training and Development : Providing continuous learning opportunities appeals to all generations, particularly Millennials and Gen Z, who seek professional growth. Generational diversity is an asset when managed effectively. By understanding and embracing the differences in work styles, communication preferences and values, organisations can create a more inclusive and dynamic work environment. The key is to find common ground, respect varying perspectives and cultivate a culture of mutual learning and collaboration.